Interesting thread. Anyone tried this?
Ginger works with ich... Every time I use it - Reef Central Online Community
Ginger works with ich... Every time I use it - Reef Central Online Community
Ginger works with ich
Treatment Option 14: Ginger
First garlic, now ginger. Is anyone else starting to get hungry? Either I am going to whip up a plate of Roasted Garlic Fettuccini Alfredo or mix up some Wasabi and get busy rolling some Sushi Maki.
Ginger is the newest homeopathic treatment to be suggested. The main thread to this discussion is located here, I waded through the entire thing. It was up to 11 pages and 258 individual posts when I read it. A good portion of the thread is devoted to an ongoing debate about whether this "experiment" was scientific and/or valid. It was neither. The next biggest group of replies debated which side of the previous debate was being rude in their replies. I would say there were some rude people who happened to be on both sides of the argument. Then there was a bunch of people posting nothing, just tagging along so they could get the email notifications. I hate to say it, but the vast majority of the replies were useless as far as determining whether or not ginger was effective at all.
I will attempt to sum up the essence of the thread to save you the time in reading it. Cratylus saw some Ich in his tank. He added ginger to his homemade frozen fish food. The Ich went away. There is no telling whether or not the ginger cured the infection or if natural immunity did. Then, Cratylus specifically purchased a Purple Tang that had a heavy infestation. He brought that fish home, placed it in a separate quarantine tank, fed it the same food, and the Ich went away again. Some people pointed to this experience as being proof. The problem is, moving a fish from an infected tank to a clean tank is a proven cure. It is one of the variations on the daily water change method that I mentioned in my first article on Cryptocaryon irritans (Colorni, 1987). In that paper, Colorni describes moving an infected fish between two tanks. The tanks are cleaned and dried between uses, thereby ridding them of tomonts. He instructs to do this every three days for ten days. This is very similar to what happened with the Purple Tang. There should have been two more moves, but Cratylus got lucky with just the one.
I want to say explicitly that I do not fault Cratylus for attempting something new. There would be no new discoveries without someone trying to push the envelope. I only wish to put his experience in light with what is already known about the biology of Cryptocaryon irritans and known methods or treatments.
not in a normal setup where the UV runs on the sumpHi Riaan, sal n uv sterilizer werk?
not in a normal setup where the UV runs on the sump
A proper QT tank where UV pulls directly from the holding tank it might. But any WS that reaches the bottom of the tank, encyst and glue themselves to the substrate will not be killed by the UV.
Then when they hatch, again, only the WS that goes through the unit will be killed.
logically, that is what should happen and I do fully agree. Also explains why a bank of tanks at the LFS, all the tanks connected are affected. So I might have been very lucky. But this is directly related to the return pump rating. Too small , low turnover rate, and the WS simply would not be washed down to the sump in great enough numbers.Free living stages are most active at night, they are poor swimmers. With good watet flow through your display these will definitely enter the sump.