Sump vs canister filters

Joined
22 Aug 2008
Posts
19
Reaction score
0
I`m wanting to get started in marines and have been trying to sift through all the information so i can get started right. I`ve been speaking to some people and some are recommending canister filters over sumps. Could someone please help me with the pros and cons of each.
 
Joined
20 Jul 2008
Posts
6,743
Reaction score
21
Location
Durban
welcometomasa
Well, i can only vouch for sumps as its all i've ever used. They are more biological, not so man made if you get my meaning? where we use what nature does to help out and its a nice place to hide all the nasty equipment we dont want in our tanks
 

Mike

Retired Moderator
Joined
12 May 2007
Posts
7,859
Reaction score
31
Location
the Motherland
Hi Garth, welcome to MASA.

A sump is used to house all the equipment that you don't want to see in your display tank, heater, skimmer, space for calcium, phosphate and carbon filters along with a DSB, it also provides a larger water volume for the benefit of your display tank which helps to lower the dangers of chemical issues, the only "cons" i can see with a sump, room to house it and the possiblilty of a flood due to blocked syphons or power loss.

External cannisters, do their job if you have little room, you can run phosphate and carbon, as well as filter floss.

If you have the room, go for a sump, the pro's outweigh the cons.
 
Joined
9 Feb 2008
Posts
1,062
Reaction score
2
Location
Empangeni
I`m wanting to get started in marines and have been trying to sift through all the information so i can get started right. I`ve been speaking to some people and some are recommending canister filters over sumps. Could someone please help me with the pros and cons of each.
Well its like this:The pros will tell you to get a sump and the cons will try to sell you a cannister filter....:lol:...

Seriously though,I'd definitely take a sump if I was you.It offers so many advantages.It holds all the stuff you don't want to see in the display.It acts as a "sin bin" for those odd nuisance creatures that just cause havoc in the tank and apart from killing them its the only other place to put them.It gives you fantastic bio-filtration.It's a place to first put things that you are not too sure about before dumping them in the main tank.It's a...........The list really just goes on.;):thumbup:
 

Kanga

Retired Moderator
Joined
7 May 2007
Posts
4,576
Reaction score
23
Location
In the Koeberg blast radius
For me the big difference is that a canister filter only performs a portion of the filtration you need in a marine tank, it is so effective in converting ammonia to nitrate that it actually becomes a nitrate factory and then it stops


Where a sump with a functioning DSB will convert nitrate into NItrite and then into nitrogen gas where the critters will stir the sand and release the gas out of your system.

Its the same argument as in this link DSB vs Bio Balls - Marine Aquariums of South Africa - wiki
 

Tobes

Retired Moderator
Joined
30 Nov 2007
Posts
9,482
Reaction score
119
Location
A Beautiful place!
Welcome to MASA. I say sump, because of the DSB you can have. Not only does it break nitrates down into nitrogen, it can also house chaetomorpha algae used for nutrient export should you prefer that - it has the space for it as it is right above the 15cm sand bed. Also a good place for copepods, amphipods and other critters to grow and multiply without predation ;)
 
Joined
4 Sep 2007
Posts
678
Reaction score
4
Location
Johannesburg
:lol: Einstein was a clever uncle hey :lol:
 
Joined
8 May 2007
Posts
2,420
Reaction score
25
Location
Durban
Well its like this:The pros will tell you to get a sump and the cons will try to sell you a cannister filter.... />
Chuckle chuckle There should be no doubt here guys. A cannister should never be used with any filter media. The flow is to fast for carbon and phos media as well. It should only be used for flow. The biggest benefit with a sump is that it allows us to surface skim. Skimmer should be able to process most if not all this water IMO these two pieces cannot be compared
 
Joined
7 May 2007
Posts
1,781
Reaction score
32
Location
Joburg
Well its like this:The pros will tell you to get a sump and the cons will try to sell you a cannister filter....:lol:...
Brilliant;).

The other quite basic thing is that its a mission cleaning a cannister and the cleaning messes with established bacteria populations. (Something difficult to clean usually doesn't get cleaned so well.)
 
Joined
10 Aug 2011
Posts
152
Reaction score
12
Location
Edenvale
Hi all was wondering if you could please help me. I want to replace my filtration in my 37l nano.
Would a canister or a sump be better?
 

deadmeat2016

Wouter
Joined
19 Jul 2009
Posts
1,506
Reaction score
22
Location
Gordons bay
generally with a sump, you want as big as you can fit under the tank, ideal would be the same size of the tank but thats unfortunately rare
 
Top