Refractometer options

Ocean

Lazy Sea Slug
Joined
14 Nov 2007
Posts
1,217
Reaction score
8
Location
CT
I would like everyones thoughts on this,
I know that a refractometer is the best way to go as it measures the water salinity perfectly (I hope), but is one better than the other or am I mostly paying for brand. I don't want to pay huge amounts of money for something I don't really need or maybe doesn't really work anyway like an extra digit on the meter (I don't know). So what is the brands you have used want to use or think are not the best, as I don't mind saving extra money for the right meter. I also would like to know how accurate the meter needs to be for happy live stock e.g. 1.000 or 1.0000 if you get that i don't know, so please talk, lead me to article or share experience you or other have had.

Jason Hargitai
 
Joined
13 Feb 2009
Posts
17
Reaction score
1
Jason, I use a Milwaukee, and can highly recommend it. I paid R400 for it about a year ago, but I gather they're considerably more than that now. Ask Sam - he stocks them.
As for accuracy, I'd say 1.000 is more than enough accuracy. The Milwaukee is marked to 3 decimal places (1.024, 1.025, 1.026 etc), but you can read between the markings quite easily (like an alcohol thermometer).

Q
 
Last edited:
Joined
22 Nov 2008
Posts
1,185
Reaction score
7
Location
Cape Town
Jason, I use a Milwaukee, and can highly recommend it. I paid R400 for it about a year ago, but I gather they're considerably more than that now. Ask Sam - he stocks them.
As for accuracy, I'd say 1.000 is more than enough accuracy. The Milwaukee is marked to 2 decimal places (1.24, 1.25, 1.26 etc), but you can read between the markings quite easily (like an alcohol thermometer).

Q
I use this as well. Paid R550 at sam's about 6 weeks ago
1392495927949c3c8.jpg
 
Joined
15 May 2007
Posts
2,899
Reaction score
117
Location
Bloemfontein
I know that a refractometer is the best way to go as it measures the water salinity perfectly
ONLY if properly calibrated - I have one which I bought about 2 years ago, and it loses it's calibration for no apparent reason. IMHO an ACCURATE glass (floating) hydrometer (such as the one supplied by Aqua Medic) is much more accurate AND repeatable than a cheap refractometer, but the refractometer is much more convenient to use, and there is much less risk of breaking the refractometer. If you can only have one instrument then I would suggest (contrary to popular advice...) that you buy a decent glass hydrometer. If you can calibrate the refractometer against a good glass hydrometer then by all means use the refractometer, but check the calibration regularly, and use the glass hydrometer as the "referee" if you get a funny reading on the refractometer.

Hennie
 
Joined
7 May 2007
Posts
1,781
Reaction score
32
Location
Joburg
I'm with Hennie.

A big glass hydrometer beats a refractometer for accuracy every time.

Tropic Marin sells one too.

I know a guy who brought in some refractometers, every one read differently after calibration. The refractometer might seem more high tech but they can be very up and down. Temp also affects them badly. Even if they are supposed to be temperature compensating.
 
Joined
28 Dec 2007
Posts
12,781
Reaction score
31
Location
JHB
Wow, this is some interesting info. I always thought my Refracto was the best.

OK, any suggestions on wht are the best Hydros ?
 
Joined
28 Dec 2007
Posts
12,781
Reaction score
31
Location
JHB
Now that is an interesting product

Wonder if it is any good ?

Reckon Glynn would import this ?
 

Ocean

Lazy Sea Slug
Joined
14 Nov 2007
Posts
1,217
Reaction score
8
Location
CT
Thanks for posting everyone I see those big glass ones at Sams aquarium all the time, I know they are much less expensive than the refractometer. I will get one today if it’s the right one, so the big glass 'saltimeter' beats the fancy refractometer. I had my eyes on the Milwaukee when I posted although I do not have much knowledge in this field of equipment, this meter you posted really does look interesting, has anyone used it can we get it here and is it worth R1300, as I said I don’t mind saving if its worth it. But you said saltimeter gave you what you needed so is this needed even if it can do what it says? And should I get a Refractometer as well as the saltimeter or is this just for ease of use and not needed?

Here is the the links page that Rory posted.

Aqua Medic Digital Specific Gravity Tester
Item# TE030
$129.89
Product Description

Marine Control Digital is a hand held digital instrument for measuring salinity and specific gravity. Simply submerge the tip of the probe into the aquarium and read the values – the fastest, easiest and safest method to measure the salt content. The gold plated electrodes are corrosion resistant for precise measurement.


Measuring range:
temperature: 0 – 100 °C
salinity: 5 – 40 g/l
specific gravity: 1.000 – 1.032


1 Year Manufactures Warranty
 
Joined
13 Feb 2009
Posts
17
Reaction score
1
For what it's worth, I test my Milwaukee against RO water (1.00), and Two Oceans NSW (1.026) weekly, and have never seen any discrepency. I'm also not convinced that accuracy beyond 4 decimal places (e.g. 1.0263) is much use, and I seem to get that comfortably with the Milwaukee.
 

Rory

Admin
Joined
5 May 2007
Posts
4,857
Reaction score
37
Location
JHB
Warr that product has been available in SA for about 2 years.
 

Rory

Admin
Joined
5 May 2007
Posts
4,857
Reaction score
37
Location
JHB
Well that was in CT, so maybe only durban and ct :p I'm sure IM would be able to get it for you. Last time I checked they were about R1100 though, sure it's gone up lots...

Easier than refractometer though, just dip it in water and push a button.
 
Joined
28 Dec 2007
Posts
12,781
Reaction score
31
Location
JHB
Yeah, it would probably be around R1700 now.

Not really worth, when you consider I use a refracto maybe once a month to check the tanks SG.

Once you have the correct measuring devices and the same salt, no point really checking SG.
 
Joined
15 May 2007
Posts
2,899
Reaction score
117
Location
Bloemfontein
Hennie you talking about this one
Marine-Hydrometers-and-Test-Kits-Aqua-Medic-salimeter.jpg
Yes, or this one from Tropic Marin

Just make sure that it has a resolution of at least 0.001.

Also, never leave it in the tank or sump between readings - algae will grow on it (and/or calcium will deposit on it...) and this will affect it's accuracy. The correct way to test with a hydrometer is to remove some water into a long, thin container (I use a 500ml measuring cylinder, but a tall vase also works quite well) and then float the instrument in it. Rinse with RO water before and after use.

Hennie
 

Ocean

Lazy Sea Slug
Joined
14 Nov 2007
Posts
1,217
Reaction score
8
Location
CT
Well I went to Sam's aquariums today with the intention of getting one, but they were out of stock and said I would have to wait a month or two for the shipment to come in. They also had a sera big glass thing but when I tested it, it was about 3 out, I looked at the tropic Marin one and it looks nice really nice but does not read low enough. As I would like to do the low salinity thing for treating fish in a seprate system, and I would need it lower, as it only goes down to 1.018 if i read right. So what should I do because I need it for setting up my system and I need a good one(accurate).
 
Joined
8 May 2007
Posts
2,420
Reaction score
25
Location
Durban
I have the Deltec refractometer, and have discovered that even the slightest bump is enough to offset the calibration.
 

Similar threads


Top