purigen vs dsb?

Joined
18 Oct 2007
Posts
6,377
Reaction score
70
Location
capetown,durbanville
a dsb is there to remove nitrates primarily? purigen removes ammonia, nitrites ,nitrates and other stuff, why bother with dsb? just use purigen? a dsb seems to be a huge crap and sediment collector in comparison to purigen. and in a dsbless nano purigen would be the answer?
 

Mekaeel

Moderator
Joined
8 May 2007
Posts
24,226
Reaction score
129
Location
Point Waterfront Durban
You can do away with a DSB. I just started mines up about 3 weeks back. and before that i did water change a month before. I tested for nitrates before i added the DSB and the it was <1. All i had was LR, Chaeto and heavy skimming.
So i would say yes. Use Purigen in the Nano.
The main reason why i started a DSB was for pods to grow.My DT is BB.
 
Joined
18 Oct 2007
Posts
6,377
Reaction score
70
Location
capetown,durbanville
ps i dont have a nano currently but purigen may help those who do. my reasoning is that why go through the mellodrama when purigen will do the job, and when it is saturated , rejuvinate or replace. o usedto have a dsb in my tank! i removed a lot of my substrate three months ago. my sump is for my skimmer and chaeto with a little coral sandfrom my ex nano!
 
Joined
5 Jan 2008
Posts
1,976
Reaction score
41
Location
JHB
Mekaeel: dont the pods all get blended up when going through the pump back into your DT?
 
Joined
22 Jul 2008
Posts
119
Reaction score
0
Location
Cap Town
the difference in opinion is that a DSB is a once off payment and it keep removing nitrates theoretically forever, while purigen has to be replaced often!I like the cheaper more natural option! if i remember purigen wasnt cheap niether?
 
Joined
10 Sep 2007
Posts
9,395
Reaction score
26
Location
Centurion
can you add a pic of the purigen please.

don't know how it works nor look.

some info will be nice too
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Alan

Admin
Joined
4 May 2007
Posts
5,974
Reaction score
123
Location
KZN
I would opt for a natural removal of a waste product above a chemical removal any day. A DSB is so low maintenance once set up its not even worth worrying about it.
 
Joined
18 Oct 2007
Posts
6,377
Reaction score
70
Location
capetown,durbanville
i just bought some chemi pure elite! it looks fantastic! removes phos plus silica. bajing there goes the need for a phos reactor! i dont have a problem with a dsb , i just like options and this is another one!
 
Joined
23 Aug 2008
Posts
4,095
Reaction score
68
Location
Honeydew, Johannesburg
I use Prodibio and have no phosphates and nitrates. No need for a DSB, phosphate sponge, nitrate sponge or algla turf scrubber. It's about R240 for 12 ampoules and that last for about six months which is about the price of a phosphate remover which lasts only two months.
 
Joined
18 Oct 2007
Posts
6,377
Reaction score
70
Location
capetown,durbanville
jar says chemi pure elite lasts 4 to six months, will monitor. cost 189 so not bad either. might be a good idea to start list of things encountered and successful solutions/options moderators?
 
Joined
23 Aug 2008
Posts
4,095
Reaction score
68
Location
Honeydew, Johannesburg
jar says chemi pure elite lasts 4 to six months, will monitor. cost 189 so not bad either. might be a good idea to start list of things encountered and successful solutions/options moderators?
Looked at one last week and here's the catch. For tanks of circa 200 litres one sachet ( 190-00). Tanks up to 400 litres 2 sachets ( 360-00). For tank of 400 litres and more, one sachet for every 100 litres. I have a tank of 700 litres so that's R1330-00. OUch and Ouch again. Prodibio about R500-00 for the same period and no I'm not a rep for them.
 
Joined
18 Oct 2007
Posts
6,377
Reaction score
70
Location
capetown,durbanville
that getsinto the area of buying a phos reactor! fortunately my tank only needs one sachet. must say i have it in my sump under overflow and will wait and see how it performs1. ps 100gallons is over 300 litres not 200l. (just mentioning)
 

jacquesb

Retired Moderator
Joined
29 May 2007
Posts
17,868
Reaction score
71
Location
Cape Town
NOTHING CAN EVER REPLACE A DSB.... The DSB has SO MANY plusses..... Purigen HAS TO BE REPLACED every so often (yes - you can try and bake it - but every time you put the same back, it is less effective....)....

A DSB becomes more and more effective as it ages...

AND it not only remove nitrates, but other chemicals as well.....

I will never have a reef tank without a DSB..... UNLESS I have a R12000 skimmer... then perhaps... but then I won't have pods to feed my fish and pod-babies to feed my corals.....
 
Joined
28 Dec 2007
Posts
12,781
Reaction score
31
Location
JHB
Purigen HAS TO BE REPLACED every so often (yes - you can try and bake it - but every time you put the same back, it is less effective....)....
Sorry Jacques, you don't bake purigen, you regenerate with bleach ;)
 

jacquesb

Retired Moderator
Joined
29 May 2007
Posts
17,868
Reaction score
71
Location
Cape Town
Sorry Jacques, you don't bake purigen, you regenerate with bleach ;)
Oops - OK then ;)

BUT what the heck......

Some folks overskim - then they do not NEED to use chemicals like Purigen....
 

Similar threads


Top