might be stupid question

FransSny

Purple Tang
Joined
16 Oct 2008
Posts
5,697
Reaction score
68
Location
Hermanus
hi guys....this might be a stupid question, im having an argument with a mate at the moment about seashells in a marine setup (i know they are bad for flow !), my question to the bioboffs is...all shells have different chemical compositions (thats why we have different colours, hardness etc)...could a lot of shells in a confined system not influence water quality.....i say yes ....he says no (tomato / patato)
 

Tobes

Retired Moderator
Joined
30 Nov 2007
Posts
9,482
Reaction score
119
Location
A Beautiful place!
I agree with Mekaeel. A lot of uneaten food and fish poo accumulates inside the shells and will cause water quality problems later on. Besides, why would one want empty shells in your tank? Rather get shells filled with a bit of snail or hermit :whistling:
 

crispin

Kingi Angel
Joined
22 Jan 2008
Posts
12,223
Reaction score
162
Location
Lilliehammer, Norway
nd if you ahve loads of spare shells which are really big, some over eager hermit takes it, lugs it around the reef and knocks everything over....believe me i know!


shells a nasty detritus traps and as for slowly breaking down and putting things into the water, rather dose with things you know you are missing, ca, or mg etc etc
 

Warr7207

Moorish Idol
Joined
28 Dec 2007
Posts
12,781
Reaction score
31
Location
JHB
Great advice for a beginner, but in my situation I encourage a certain amount of detritus due to the large clean up crew I have.

And they would starve if it were not for these little crevices collecting ****.
 

crispin

Kingi Angel
Joined
22 Jan 2008
Posts
12,223
Reaction score
162
Location
Lilliehammer, Norway
Great advice for a beginner, but in my situation I encourage a certain amount of detritus due to the large clean up crew I have.

And they would starve if it were not for these little crevices collecting ****.
ummm not maybe a thought to sell some cuc and keep better water quality :) :lol:

but for begoniers and as a rule of thumb i would say shells are far more bad than good
 

Renier

Shrimp
Joined
22 Aug 2007
Posts
259
Reaction score
3
would play sand not cause allot of sillica to be released in the water.
which in turn would feaul unwanted algae growth?

Correct me if im wrong please!!
 

Storm

Chromis
Joined
1 Apr 2008
Posts
728
Reaction score
5
Location
East London
Since we are on the topic of sea shells. What are your peoples opinions on very fine crushed sea shells? (1-2)mm
 

scubaninja

Achilles Tang
Joined
20 Jul 2008
Posts
6,743
Reaction score
21
Location
Durban
i think the question was more directed to chemical make up. I dont think that the shells make up itself would add to the paramter levels of the tank but i would not know about it degrading, might increase calcium?
 

Storm

Chromis
Joined
1 Apr 2008
Posts
728
Reaction score
5
Location
East London
i think the question was more directed to chemical make up. I dont think that the shells make up itself would add to the paramter levels of the tank but i would not know about it degrading, might increase calcium?
Would do more good then bad if you asked me, crushed anyways.
 

Tobes

Retired Moderator
Joined
30 Nov 2007
Posts
9,482
Reaction score
119
Location
A Beautiful place!
would play sand not cause allot of sillica to be released in the water.
which in turn would feaul unwanted algae growth?

Correct me if im wrong please!!
Renier, why don't you start your own thread under new members and tell us more about yourself and your setup (if you have one) or what you want to do. You'll get a warm Masa welcome from the guys. I didn't see anything, but if you did it already, apologies for I am sleeping :p
 

FransSny

Purple Tang
Joined
16 Oct 2008
Posts
5,697
Reaction score
68
Location
Hermanus
Thanks guys ....obviously opened up a can of worms here...I agree regarding detritus build up.....im thinking calcium +++ over time as per scubaninja...just an interesting subject for me .....o ye i also like to discuss things (my wife calls it arguing)
 

Mtroboer

Chromis
Joined
7 Mar 2008
Posts
639
Reaction score
5
Location
Kimberley
Says ME MUAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!:lol::lol::lol:
 

MyKey

Bristleworm
Joined
6 Sep 2007
Posts
88
Reaction score
0
Location
Midrand
If you have hermit, I do think that you should have a few shells laying around for them to swop.. But then the question is how many shells do you want laying empty in your tank. I have about 20 hermits and about 6 emptly shells in my tank that they swop with all the time.. Is this a bad thing?
 

ben lloyd

Cardinal
Joined
23 Jun 2008
Posts
1,344
Reaction score
3
Location
kzn dundee
my hermis in my sump swap their shell regaler i think you must have a couple shells laying around for them as they grow to fit into an bigger shell
 

bushwacker_69

Shrimp
Joined
20 Jan 2008
Posts
241
Reaction score
0
what about carib sea grand bahamas oolite....this is sugar fine but sold with tons of shells in it....
 

Top