Advice on stocking options

Joined
7 Feb 2015
Posts
450
Reaction score
52
Location
Pretoria
Hi guys,

Just want some advice and personal experiences on stocking and which fish to put in my 4ft 450L tank...

So far I have 2 picasso clowns, an orchid dottyback and a bicolor blenny which are all doing well.

Then I have been looking at the following:

1) Suntail (pinkbar) goby;
2) Flame angel;
3) Blue Throat trigger;
4) Yellow eye kole tang.

I have good filtration with a skimmer rated for 1000L and use about 6kg of Seachem Matrix.

The list I have given is by no means a closed list so please feel free to make suggestions? I am wanting to have fairly easy-moderate to care for community fish but want some different things (not the everyday LFS fish).

Also, would you say I am over stocked at all with the current list?

Thanks guys!
 
Joined
27 Nov 2014
Posts
246
Reaction score
111
Location
Bloemfontein, Freestate
Are you planning to eventually turn it into a reef? If yes then the trigger is a bad idea and most angels are 50/50 whether they are going to eat corals.
The rest looks fine to me, although some will say the 4ft is too short for a tang.
 
Last edited:
Joined
7 Feb 2015
Posts
450
Reaction score
52
Location
Pretoria
Been reading a lot about the blue throat and have seen a few tanks (my size and bigger) where a blue throat has been a model citizen... Should I take this as being the exception rather than the rule?

Yeah I am a bit worried about the angel being 50/50 and I am hoping that given the 4ft length a Kole tang (as opposed to other tangs) will be OK...

Any suggestions to replace these possible fish with better/more suitable candidates? Is the tank far too small to consider 3 lyretail anthias (1 male and 2 female)?
 
Joined
27 Nov 2014
Posts
246
Reaction score
111
Location
Bloemfontein, Freestate
I also really wanted to get a blue throat but the risk is always there. Anthias are really great fish but they have a large bioload because you have to feed them so much, but you might be able to do 3, but also look at the reef safe wrasses, some are really beautiful.
Also i think the tang will be fine, you could
Prob get away with +-8 medium sized fish in that tank.

What i would do:
2 x clowns
Orchid dottyback
Bicolor blenny

Kole tang
Flame angel i would maybe replace with something like a yellow longnose butterfly for vibrant color,
Replace the trigger with a nice wrasse or the anthias

But this is a very personal choice, no one can decide for you.
 

RiaanP

Moderator
Joined
11 Aug 2008
Posts
25,981
Reaction score
2,106
Location
Centurion
Flame angels are generally reef safe. Unless you forget to feed it a nice variety and they realize that some corals are food. Normally they are OK.

The trigger I would leave alone. They get bigger than your other fish listed.

Midas Blennie for some yellow. Or yellow wrasse.
Coral beauty as alternative to Flame. Although not that vibrant in color, they are cheaper.
One or two blue yellow tail damsels. Tank big enough for it to set a place for himself and others to get away.
Tangs generally prefer bigger than 4 foot. Smaller tangs like Chocolate maybe.
 

RiaanP

Moderator
Joined
11 Aug 2008
Posts
25,981
Reaction score
2,106
Location
Centurion
not as much as a powder blue. But all tangs can get whitespot. Some just more than others. Same for most of our little friends

Best is to have a dedicated hospital tank. Even one out in the garage. I bucket treat all new fish for 10 days. Then keep them in quarantine another 5 weeks. This way I cannot get any WS into my display.
 
Joined
23 Feb 2015
Posts
3,093
Reaction score
746
Location
Sandton
not as much as a powder blue. But all tangs can get whitespot. Some just more than others. Same for most of our little friends

Best is to have a dedicated hospital tank. Even one out in the garage. I bucket treat all new fish for 10 days. Then keep them in quarantine another 5 weeks. This way I cannot get any WS into my display.
Thanks, I will be getting my QT Tank before I get any live stock.
 
Joined
7 Feb 2015
Posts
450
Reaction score
52
Location
Pretoria
Thanks for the replies!

I think I am going to go the anthius route and take it slowly after that... Definitely still keen on the goby and will look into the chocolate tang over the kole tang... The flame angel is also one of the reasons I started this hobby so will look at that being one of the last fish and will give him a good 30 day quarantine and be sure to feed a variety as suggested by @RiaanP

Already have the bicolor in there so think I will have to pass on the midas, hopefully the two female anthius will replace that yellow...
 

RiaanP

Moderator
Joined
11 Aug 2008
Posts
25,981
Reaction score
2,106
Location
Centurion
You still need to be able to observe the fish. Rather use plastic ABS sheet on the sides, that you can remove. Nice size plastic flower pit in the QT would help to provide enough hiding place for the fish. Brown plastic pot is better than a white ice cream tub. Looks a lot more natural for the fish as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EFJ

Similar threads


Top