MASA - Marine Aquariums of South Africa
Home Forums Useful Resources Glossary iTrader
Go Back   Marine Aquariums South Africa > >
RegisterToday's Posts Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Notices

General Discussions General discussion forum about reefkeeping and marine tanks.

Reply
   
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 10-11-2009   #1
ziyaadb
 
Main InfoStats and RepSocial and Albums
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: JHB-Lenzz
Posts: 5,544
Rep: ziyaadb is a name known to all
ziyaadb is a name known to allziyaadb is a name known to allziyaadb is a name known to all
Default Do Butterflies and Angelfish eat SPS?
I have heard and read that angels can nip at SPS . Nip at is different from eating the coral up. Do butterflies actually eat SPS up? what happens to the SPS when they are nipped at? do they die? The only fish that i know of that has evolved to Actually eat the actual coral is the parrot fish. and thanks to them eating the corals we get lovely arognite. IS nipping really so bad for sps that they die from it? I have read that they eat the slime thats produced and at times the coral actually colours up better.

Your experiences?

__________________

"Remember, it's a hobby and if it is not fun, or is a cause for worry, or if I can't afford it, it goes in the garbage. but one thing I will never lose any sleep over is a fish tank." Paul B

My tank Thread
http://www.marineaquariumsa.com/medium-tanks/18678-the-130-fish-box-with-some-softies.html
ziyaadb is offline  
    Reply With Quote

  #ADS
Ads
Registered users do not see these google ads. Register today! It's free.
 
 
 
Join Date: Always
Location: Advertising world
Age: 2010
Posts: Many
 


__________________

Ads is online  
Old 10-11-2009   #2
Prodigy
 
Prodigy's Avatar
 
My Aquarium Specs
Main InfoStats and RepSocial and Albums
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Slums Baby!!!
Posts: 1,107
Rep: Prodigy is an unknown quantity at this point
Default
Bi colour angel nipped at my sps corals the only thing that happened was the polyps closed and u never saw them, but they still grew and colour was normal although they didnt grow as fast...

__________________

Prodigy is offline       Reply With Quote
Old 10-11-2009   #3
chikaboo
 
chikaboo's Avatar
 
My Aquarium Specs
Main InfoStats and RepSocial and Albums
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Newcastle - KZN
Posts: 4,923
Rep: chikaboo is a name known to allchikaboo is a name known to allchikaboo is a name known to allchikaboo is a name known to allchikaboo is a name known to allchikaboo is a name known to allchikaboo is a name known to allchikaboo is a name known to allchikaboo is a name known to allchikaboo is a name known to allchikaboo is a name known to allchikaboo is a name known to allchikaboo is a name known to allchikaboo is a name known to allchikaboo is a name known to all
Default
Well I'm sitting with most of Scuba's angels coz they were being naughty and my 2 Marlia butterflies were swopped with a friend in Phoenix coz they were filling their gullets with coral from his 2M tank

__________________

http://www.marineaquariumsa.com/large-tanks/8832-chikaboos-2nd-marine-tanks-discussion-thread.html - My eye candy
Let's all be masters of our mouths, so that we won't be slaves of our
words
If you can't have the best ... make the best of what you have

Never fear death.... Only an unliving life!
chikaboo is offline       Reply With Quote
Old 10-11-2009   #4
lanzo
 
lanzo's Avatar
 
Main InfoStats and RepSocial and Albums
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Centurion
Posts: 9,391
Rep: lanzo is a name known to all
lanzo is a name known to all
Default
Angels:

i have an indian ...angel...forgot the name( will post it tomorrow) in a stock tank.

She came out of a Hammer coral tank.( the tank is fully stocked with hammers...sock an block), so i placed her in a stock tasnk with diff corals in...some sps ...some favia's and a couple of torches and hammers. She ate all the pocillapora's over night...and irritated the favia's over 2 days that some also started dieng, but the one acro that was in there she left alone( i moved her to a her own tank after that)

ziyaad i think it depends all about the sertain sp. of angel(the larger angels) like the emperor....a gental giant that only loves zoa's out of my experiance(but only as they grow up), Regal angels will make mins out of xenia...same for the majestic angel.....but i have never noticed that the went for any sps .(in any of my clients setups)

The queen i have seen bite a chunk out of a montipora...aswell as a millapora

thats my 2c on angels

__________________

]
lanzo is offline       Reply With Quote
Old 10-11-2009   #5
Mekaeel
 
Mekaeel's Avatar
 
Main InfoStats and RepSocial and Albums
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Point Waterfront Durban
Posts: 24,083
Rep: Mekaeel has a reputation beyond repute
Mekaeel has a reputation beyond reputeMekaeel has a reputation beyond reputeMekaeel has a reputation beyond reputeMekaeel has a reputation beyond reputeMekaeel has a reputation beyond reputeMekaeel has a reputation beyond reputeMekaeel has a reputation beyond reputeMekaeel has a reputation beyond reputeMekaeel has a reputation beyond repute
Default
Ok, here's my experience with SPS and Angels. My Emperor and French take the odd nip on the coral. From what I have noticed, especially on the tips where the fish has nipped, the corals starts taking a new formation. In other words, that single tip will become multiple. I have never had a case where the Angel's wiped out an entire colony.

__________________



SEEK KNOWLEDGE FROM THE CRADLE TO THE GRAVE!

My current system
My old SPS Reef
MY old 1.8m SPS Reef




Mekaeel is offline       Reply With Quote
Old 10-11-2009   #6
durleo
 
durleo's Avatar
 
My Aquarium Specs
Main InfoStats and RepSocial and Albums
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: durban
Posts: 1,247
Rep: durleo is a glorious beacon of lightdurleo is a glorious beacon of lightdurleo is a glorious beacon of lightdurleo is a glorious beacon of lightdurleo is a glorious beacon of lightdurleo is a glorious beacon of lightdurleo is a glorious beacon of lightdurleo is a glorious beacon of lightdurleo is a glorious beacon of light
Default
Hi Guys

I have 2 bi-colour angels and they dont seem to bother my frogspawn-bubble-zoas-sinularia-hammer-fox or mushrooms - but then i saw this cool red brain and the minute i added it they went Candy Crazy I thought it was jus a phase so i left it over night -
The next morning the poor brain was fully retracted and i thought it was dead .
I put it in my sump for a day and it recovered like nothing had even happened -
So i sadly returned it to the LFS and wont be putting any in my tank soon
durleo is offline       Reply With Quote
Reply


Tags
angelfish, butterflies, eat, sps

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search




All times are GMT +2. The time now is 12:32 PM.


Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
  All content Copyright 2007-2014, marineaquariumsa.com
SA Topsites ::